Two passengers attempted to stop a British Airways Boeing 777-200 from taking off
from a Caribbean airport last September, after realising the crew had lined up
at the wrong runway intersection, but were too late to prevent the departure.
The pilots of the twin-jet, bound for Antigua, had intended to depart
from the south-western end of runway 07 - the 'A' intersection - at St Kitts'
Bradshaw International Airport.
Despite specifically requesting a departure from 'A', the aircraft
mistakenly taxied instead for the 'B' intersection, near the runway's midpoint,
leaving available take-off distance of just 1,220m (4,000ft). The take-off
performance calculations had been based on a distance of 1,915m.
The oversight escaped detection despite several references and queries
in the communications between the crew and air traffic control.
The UK Air Accidents Investigation Branch reveals that the carrier's
station engineer and airport duty manager were on board the 777 and realised
the error as the aircraft lined up on the runway.
The engineer quickly moved from his seat to speak to a member of the
cabin crew, telling her that he needed to contact the pilots immediately to
warn them the aircraft was wrongly positioned.
In the cockpit the captain had specifically commented that the runway
looked short. Neither pilot had been to the airport before and the lack of a
tractor meant the crew had taxied the jet from the stand themselves. But, in
spite of the captain's concerns, neither cross-checked the jet's location on
the runway. Instead the captain told the co-pilot to "stand on the
brakes", says the AAIB, and apply a high thrust setting - some 55% of N1
level - before releasing the brakes for the take-off roll.
In the cabin behind, the station engineer realised that the aircraft was
powering up for take-off and abandoned his bid to reach the crew. The 777
accelerated but reached the touchdown-zone markers for the reverse-direction
runway 25 by the time it passed the crucial V1 decision speed, and lifted off
about 300m from the end of the paved surface.
Taking off from the 'B' intersection reduces the available distance by
1,110m and the AAIB says that British Airways does not authorise 777 departures
from this point on runway 07.
The incident, on 26 September last year, occurred in daylight although
the sun was low in the west.
While the AAIB attributes the event to simple lack of familiarity
with the airport, combined with disorientation from poor signage, it also
underlines the psychological factors which contributed to the failure to
identify the error.
Bradshaw is a simple airport, and the crew did not conduct a taxi
briefing. The AAIB says that the crew would probably have briefed the route at
a larger, more complex airport.
It adds that the crew appears to have suffered from "confirmation
bias", noticing only the evidence that backed their mistaken assumption of
being at the correct intersection.
Crew resource management training should address this tendency in two
ways, says the AAIB: by emphasising the need to "seek evidence that
disproves assumptions whenever they are called into doubt" and by
providing communications skills needed for "confident and clear
discussion" of the problem.
No comments:
Post a Comment